The Laurie Ann is a 2008 model with the 110 Yanmar. We have 400 hours on the engine and about 2,400 boating miles under the hull. We had a 25-35 knot Bayliner before the Ranger and had sailboats in the marina for 10 years before going into power. Like the previous owners mentioned, we are satisfied with the 8 to 10 knot speed. However, it was an adjustment from the Bayliner and I was first hoping to cruise at 12 knots when we got the Ranger. For the first year of having the Laurie Ann, we cruised at 2,800 RPM doing 10-11 knots. Then, we did a 90-day, 1,600 miles of the Tennessee River Valley during the height of the fuel prices and we grew to love cruising at 1800 to 2100 RPM and doing 7 knots. On the rivers everything is measured in statute miles, so we did 8 MPH and enjoyed 5 miles to the gallon. When you look at the performance graphs for the Yanmar 110, it reaches max torque at about 2200 RPM and is wide open throttle at 3,200 RPM. In other words, a very strong package at a great cruising speed.
This past weekend, we took the Laurie Ann out from Everett, WA in Puget Sound during small craft warnings to go to Winslow on Bainbridge Island. The wind was 25 to 30 with oncoming seas of 3 to 5 feet high. By the way, NOAA uses wave height averaging in their forecasts and that means when it is 3-5 feet, you are going to have a waves that are higher. We motored along at 8 knots in the head wind and waves hitting the bow while running at 2,600 RPM. We pitched and dropped over the waves taking a lot of spray but never a wave over the bow. The boat was great but when the cat lost her cookies on the floor, the admiral ordered that we turn around.
Our boating friends have a 24 foot Rosborough with twin outboard engines that likes to cruise at 14 knots. They could not go any faster in the wind and waves but did power out faster when we turned around. They use a lot more fuel than we do and have more maintenance issues with the outboards. My point being, is that everything in boating is a compromise. I really like the Yanmar 110 because I do the routine maintenance and there is enough room in the engine space to work in. The Cummins is a great product also but it is a bigger engine in that space.
It is really your choice. If the factory offered to swap out the Yanmar for the bigger Cummins engine for free-I would take the offer. How is that for mixed messages?
John