The aft helm station came on our boat, which we bought off the boat show floor. I would not have considered it a must have item if I had been configuring everything from scratch. Now, having had it, I would not be quick to give it up.
For me, it’s value is in single-handing the boat on and off the dock. I don’t use the aft helm in every outing or in all situations. Also, getting comfortable with it has taken and continues to take practice. But with that practice, from the aft helm I can single-hand off the dock in some situations that would be very challenging (or maybe simply not possible without help from someone on the dock) if I were limited to the front helm. Same goes for a few ways I get back on the dock. Most of those situations involve stronger or otherwise dicey wind and current.
I would never give up the helm door in exchange for the aft helm station. I love that door for the visibility it gives me, as well as the near-instant access on and off the dock to handle and secure lines. I use the helm door to one degree or another departing and docking 100 percent of the time. But the aft helm station has also proven its worth to me, and I hope to use it to increasingly good advantage over time.
Gini