I'm sure you agree the shower sump and sensor are difficult to access. On our R-25, they were buried under the hoses to the shower - and one hose came off the shower behind the wall when I foolishly had a mechanic work on the shower with the problems you described above.
Eventually, I bit the bullet (or the sump in this case), and cut it in half, removed it, and removed the pump and sensor.
In its place, I installed a pump protector (the screen thing you have in the air conditioner and generator lines) and a rule in-line 3/4" pump. This is not automatic so I installed a switch next to the head flush switch.
When the shower starts to fill, I turn on the pump for about 30 seconds and it pumps the shower floor dry.
Since it is a fact that shower sump systems eventually clog with dirt, hair and stuff, the protector is easily accessible immediately under the original access plate (unmodified). There is, however, ample room to work since the new pump is only very slightly larger than the hose.
It is quiet, the switch is lighted, and te positive control of the shower drain (rather than waiting for the slow shower sup to notice you are standing up to your toes in water) is very nice.
Easy 2 hour project, not very inexpensive, and it captures the best part of showers on boats we had in the past.
Rule makes an automatic switch, but that seemed like extra complication so I skipped it.