I replaced the raw water impeller on my 4BY2 in about an hour (with a second set of smaller hands to get the "O" ring in place.
The new impeller is a Globe #100 Model Number P/N 01-12-1060.
Amazon has them back in stock for about $56. It comes well lubricated in a bubble pack marked "Run" and is pre-"greased" for easier insertion. It is also packed with a full set of gaskets and "O" rings for various pumps. The material is much more flexible than the Johnson original and is a lovely blue color.
Replacement on my 2010/2011 R-25 classic takes about an hour, many band aids, and several new words. The new impeller was followed by new exhaust hose and a new Vetus NLP-90 muffler. After installing the muffler, I learned that Vetus now makes a NLP-90 HD that is stocked by Defender, about $200 more, and withstands over 500 degrees without damage.
All the time I was curious why Ranger did not specify the engine with a manifold temperature sensor (standard option on Yanmar engines) or an after market raw water flow/temperature gauge (about $100). Seems a fair question for a high end boat builder.